LEGAL VOCABULARY OF ARABIC-SPEAKING ‘ADAT MONUMENTS IN 14TH-20TH CENTURY DAGESTAN (SOME RESULTS OF THE STUDY OF ISLAMIC DISCOURSES)

Authors

  • Vladimir Olegovic Bobrovnikov Institute of Oriental Studies, RAS, Moscow, Russia; National Research University Higher School of Economics in St. Petersburg, Russia; Research Laboratory for Analysis and Modeling of Social Processes Saint Petersburg State University, Russia 0000-0002-1444-7722 (unauthenticated)

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.32653/CH162291-315

Keywords:

Arabic language, Dagestan, legal custom, cultural translation, discourse analysis.

Abstract

The present article attempts at compiling a concise historical-legal dictionary of the legal custom or ‘adat practiced by Muslim highlanders in the North-East Caucasus from the 14th to the 20th centuries. It contains 108 terminological and phraseological items that the author gathered from documents as well as normative and narrative texts, including inscriptions. Characteristic for these terms and expressions is the inaccurate use of Arabic morphology and semantics. The author argues that these inaccuracies reflect the cultural translation of Dagestani historical realities into Arabic. The legal vocabulary of Dagestani ‘adat texts was created by Shari‘a judges as well as teachers and students of madrasas – that is, by persons with a rather good knowledge of classical Islamic legal literature – for members of their own rural communities and confederacies. ‘Adat agreements that had been concluded at meetings of the confederations were thereby translated into Arabic and written down in the margins of mosque Qur’ans and legal manuals; this process of translation and fixation in manuscript gave legitimacy to the agreements. The glossary offered here is meant to help readers of Arabophone sources from the North-East Caucasus. At the same time, the present publication points out controversies in the Islamic discourse that centered on issues of Dagestani ‘adat. The latter is understood here as a changing legal custom operating in the frameworks of Islamic law and then of the Russian imperial and early Soviet legal systems. Over the past twenty years, historians have analyzed the discourse of Dagestani scholars such as Muhammad of Kudutl, Dawud of Usisha and Murtada-‘Ali of Urada who in the seventeenth to nineteenth centuries took part in the Shari‘a movement against non-Islamic local customs. The present article draws attention to the circumstance that in judicial practice, these Shari‘a-minded scholars had to refer to various ‘adat norms and procedures reflecting the early modern society they lived in. At the same time, they contributed to gradual Islamization of legal custom. This process is reflected in the changing meanings of the terms as presented in this paper.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

  • Vladimir Olegovic Bobrovnikov, Institute of Oriental Studies, RAS, Moscow, Russia; National Research University Higher School of Economics in St. Petersburg, Russia; Research Laboratory for Analysis and Modeling of Social Processes Saint Petersburg State University, Russia
    Bio Statement: PhD (in History), professor, Senior Researcher of the Center for the study of Central Asia, the Caucasus and the Ural-Volga region at the Institute of Eastern studies, RAS, Leading Researcher of the Centre for Historical Research at the HSE Campus in St. Petersburg (St. Petersburg School of Social Sciences and Humanities) Personal URL: https://ivran.academia.edu/BobrovnikovVladimir esearcher focus: Islam, history and social anthropology of the Muslim village in the North Caucasus, the history of oriental studies, Orientalism

References

Osmanova MN. Catalogue of old printed books issued in Arabic language by the Dagestani publishers in Russia and abroad in the beginning of the twentieth century. [Katalog pechatnykh knig na arabskom yazyke, vypuschennykh dagestanskimi izdatel’stvami v Rossii i za rubezhom v nachale ХХ veka]. Makhachkala: , 2008:204. (In Russ).

Lavrov LI., compiler and editor, Epigraphic monuments of the Northern Caucasus in Arabic, Persian, ad Turkish languages [Epigraficheskie pamyatniki Severnogo Kavkaza na arabskom, persidskom i turetskom yazykakh]. Pt. 1. Inscriptions of the 10th-17th centuries [Nadpisi X–XVII vv.]. Moscow: Nauka, 1966:300. (In Russ).

Khashaev Kh-M., Saidov M-S., editors, ‘Adat-book of Gidatl’. [Gidatlinskie adaty]. Makhachkala: Dagestani branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences Press, 1957:41. (In Russ).

Saidov M.-S. Avar-Russian dictionary. [Avarsko-russkiy slovar’]. Moscow: “Sovetskaya entsiklopediya” Publ., 1967:806. (In Russ).

Gadzhiev MG., Davudov OM., Shikhsaidov AR. History of Dagestan from the pre-historical times to the end of the fifteenth century. [Istoriya Dagestana s drevneyshikh vremen do kontsa XV v.]. Makhachkala: DNTs RAN Press, 1996:462. (In Russ).

Shikhsaidov AR. Essays on history, source studies, and archeography of medieval Dagestan. [Ocherki istorii, istochnikovedeniya, arkheografii srednevekovogo Dagestana]. Makhachkala: Dagestan Books Publishers, 2008:560. (In Russ).

Aytberov TM. On the question of djizya in the Avar princedom (XVII–XIX centuries). [K voprosu o dzhizye v Avarskom nutsal’stve (XVII–XIX vv.)]. In: Written monuments and problems of of cultural history of the peoples of the East. XIth annual scientific session of the Leningrad branch of the Institute of Oriental studies, Academy of sciences of the USSR (summaries and auto-annotations). Moscow: “Nauka” Publ., 1975:3-6. (In Russ).

Aytberov TM. Dagestani documents dating XV-XVII centuries. [Dagestanskie documenty XV-XVII vv.]. In: Written monuments of the East. 1975 Yearbook. [Pis’mennye pamyatniki Vostoka. Ezhegodnik 1975 g.]. Moscow: “Nauka” Publ., 1982:4-12. (In Russ).

Magomedova PT., Khalilova RSh. Karata-Russian dictionary. [Karatinsko-russkiy slovar’]. St. Petersburg, Makhachkala: “Scriptorium” Publ., 2001:474. (In Russ).

Dzhidalaev NS., editor and compiler, Social terminology in Dagestani languages. [Sotsial’naya terminologiya v dagestanskikh yazykakh]. Makhachkala: Dagestani branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences Press, 1989:152. (In Russ).

Krishtopa AE. Dagestan in the 13th – beginning of the 15th centuries (Essays on political history). [Dagestan v XIII – nachale XV vv. (Ocherki politicheskoy istorii)]. Moscow: “Taus” Publ., 2007:228. (In Russ).

Bobrovnikov VO. North Caucasus Muslims: custom, law, and violence (Essays on legal history and anthropology of Mountain Dagestan). [Musul’mane Severnogo Kavkaza: obychay, pravo, nasilie (Ocherki po istorii i etnografii prava Nagornogo Dagestana)]. Moscow: “Vostochnaya literatura” Publ., 2002:368. (In Russ).

Mahmud of Khinalug. Events in Dagestan and Shirvan in the XIV-XV centuries. [Sobytiya v Dagestane i Shirvane v XIV-XV vv.]. Shikhsaidov A.R., translator, compiler, editor. Makhachkala: Dagestan Books Publishers, 1997:208. (In Russ).

Kemper M. Power, law and Islam in Dagestan. From the khanates and village confederacies to the jihad-state. [Herrschaft, Recht und Islam in Daghestan. Von den Khanaten und Gemeindebünden bis zum ğihād-Staat]. Wiesbaden: Reichert, 2005:462. (In Germ).

Bobrovnikov VO., Shekhmagomedov MG., Shikhaliev ShSh. Muslim law and custom in Russia’s Dagestan: sources and studies. Reader. [Musul’manskoe pravo i obychay v rossiyskom Dagestane: istochniki i issledovaniya. Khrestomatiya]. St. Petersburg: President Library Publ., 2017:319. (In Russ).

Aytberov TM. History of state and law in Dagestan in the XVIII-XIX centuries: Reader. [Khrestomatiya po istorii prava i gosudarstva Dagestana v XVIII-XIX vv.]; Pt. 1-2. Makhachkala: Dagestani State University Press, 1998–1999:126,120. (In Russ).

Bobrovnikov VO., compiler and editor, Custom and Law in the Dagestani written monuments from the 5th to the beginning of the 20th centuries. [Obychay i zakon v pis’mennykh pamyatnikakh Dagestana V - nachala XX v.]; Vol. I. Before the Russian conquest. [Do prisoedineniya k Rossii]; Vol. II. Under the tsarist and early Soviet rule. [V tsarskoy i ranney sovetskoy Rossii]. Moscow: Marjani Publishing House, 2009:248;272. (In Russ).

Kemper M. Communal Agreements (ittifaqat) and ‘adat-Books from Daghestani Villages and Confederacies (18th–19th Centuries). Der Islam. 2004;(81):115–151.

Aglarov MA. Village community in Highland Dagestan in the XVII - beginning of the XIX centuries. [Sel’skaya obschina v Nagornom Dagestane v XVII - nachale XIX v.]; 2nd ed. Makhachkala: Institute of History, Archeology and Ethnography Press, 2014:290. (In Russ).

Saidov M-S., editor, Catalogue of Arabic manuscripst of the Gamzat Tsadasa Institute of history, language and literature of the Dagestani branch of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR. [Katalog arabskikh rukopisey Instituta istorii, yazyka i litertury im. Gamzata Tsadasy Dagestanskogo filiala AN SSSR]; Issue I. Moscow: “Nauka” Publ., 1977:91. (In Russ).

Kemper M. Was there an ethnographic descriptions of customary law ordered by the Russians? [Araboyzychnaya etnografiya adata po russkomu zakazu?]. In: Shikhsaidov A.R., editor, Dagestan’s relics [Dagestanskie svyatyni]. Makhachkala: Epokha Publ., 2013; 3:175–190. (In Russ).

Statutes in the explanation of established village communities of the Dagestani Province, their administration, state and social services. [Hadhihi qawa‘id fi bayan jama‘at qura vilayat al-Daghistan wa-tadbir umuri-him wa-l’ huquq al-qajiba ‘ala ahali-l’ qura li’l’ fadishahiyya wa-l’ jama‘a]. Temir-Khan-Shura: Dagestani Headquarters Press, 1868:19. (In Arab).

Bobrovnikov VO. Arabic agreement (ittifaq) as a sort of socio-normative acts in 18th-19th century Dagestan. [Araboyzychnoe soglashenie (ittifaq) kak vid normativnogo akta v Dagestane XVIII–XIX vv.]. Vostok. 2003;(4):43-52. (In Russ).

Zakariyaev ZSh. On the question of contents of the Arabic inscription dated 1815 of the historical legal type of “ittifaq” in the cathedral mosque of the village of Mishlesh. [K voprosu o soderzhanii araboyazychnoy nadpisi 1815 g. istoriko-pravovogo zhanra “ittifaq” na sobornoy mecheti seleniya Mishlesh]. Vestnik Dagestanskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2011;(4):10-12. (In Russ).

Tyan E. Arsh. In: Lewis B., Pellat Ch., Schacht J., Burton-Page J., Dumont C., Ménage V.L., editors, The Encyclopaedy of Islam. 2nd ed. Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1991; II:340-343.

Shikhsaidov AR., Orazaev GM-R., Aytberov TM. Dagestani historical writings. [Dagestanskie istoricheskie sochineniya]. Moscow: “Nauka. Vostochnaya literatura” Publ., 1993:302. (In Russ).

Omarov KhA. 100 Shamil’s letters. [100 pisem Shamilya]. Makhachkala: Dagestani Scientific Centre Press, 1997:320. (In Arab. and Russ).

Sharafutdinova RSh., compiler, translator, and editor, Arabic documents of the Shamil’s rule. [Araboyazychnye dokumenty epokhi Shamilya]. Moscow: “Vostochnaya literatura” Publ., 2001:262. (In Arab. and Russ).

Shikhsaidov AR. Epigraphic monuments of 10th–17th centuries Dagestan’s as a historical source. [Epigraficheskie pamyatniki Dagestana X-XVII vv. kak istoricheskiy istochnik]. Moscow: “Nauka” Publ., 1984:463. (In Russ).

Dzhidalaev NS., Aytberov TM. On the term “uzden” in the North-Eastern Caucasus. [O termine “uzden” na Severo-Vostochnom Kavkaze]. In: Dzhidalaev N.S., editor and compiler, Social terminology in Dagestani languages. [Sotsial’naya terminologiya v dagestanskikh yazykakh]. Makhachkala: Dagestani branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences Press, 1989:14-32. (In Russ).

Muhammed Tahir al-Qarakhi’s Chronicle. On Dagestan’s wars under the rule of Shamil. [Khronika Muhammeda Takhira al-Karakhi. O dagestanskikh voynakh v period Shamilya]. Barabanov A.M., editor of the Arabic text under direction of Academician Krachkovsky I.Yu. Moscow; Leningrad: Academy of Sciences of the USSR Press, 1946:311. (In Arab).

Heyd U. Djurm. In: Lewis B., Pellat Ch., Schacht J., Burton-Page J., Dumont C., Ménage V.L., editors, The Encyclopaedy of Islam. 2nd ed. Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1991;(II): 604.

Cahen C., Inalcik H., Hardy P. Djizya. In: Lewis B., Pellat Ch., Schacht J., Burton-Page J., Dumont C., Ménage V.L., editors, The Encyclopaedy of Islam. 2nd ed. Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1991;(II): 559-567.

Aliev BG. Legends, monuments, historical sketches of Dagestan. [Predaniya, pamyatniki, istoricheskie zarisovki o Dagestane]. Makhachkala: Dagestan Books Publ., 1988:128. (In Russ).

Hinz W. Muslim weights and measures. [Musul’manskie mery i vesa]. Bregel Yu.E., translator; Davidovich E.A. Materials on metrology in medieval Central Asia [Materialy po metrologii srednevekovoy Sredney Azii]. Moscow: “Nauka” Publ., 1970:148. (In Russ).

Bobrovnikov V. Waqf Endowments in Daghestani Village Communities from the 1917 Revolution to the Collectivization. Die Welt des Islams. 2010;(50: 3-4):477-502.

Bobrovnikov V. Arabic inscriptions of the 16th-20th centuries ofIslanmization of the Dagestani Mountaineers [Arabskaya epigrafika XVI-XX vv. ob islamizatsii gortsev Severnogo Dagestana. In: Voprosy epigraphiki. Moscow: Dmitry Pozharsky University Press, 2009;(III):30-53. (In Russ).

[Aliev BG., Akhmedov ShM., Bulatova AG, Gasanov MR., Ichalov GKh., Shikhsaidov AR.]. Materials on metrology of Dagestan’s peoples [Materialy po metrologii narodov Dagestana]. In: Gadzhiev V.G., editor; Questions of Dagestan’s history: pre-Soviet period [Voprosy istorii Dagestana (dosovetskiy period)]. Makhachkala: Dagestani branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences Press, 1974;(I): 166–182. (In Russ).

Shikhsaidov AR. Mulk in 10th-14th centuries Dagestan. [Mulk v Dagestane X-XIV vv.]. In: Forms of feudal land property in the Near and Middle East. 1975 Bartol’d readings. [Formy feodal’noy zemel’noy sobstvennosti na Blizhnem i Srednem Vostoke. Bartol’dovskie chteniya 1975 g.]. Moscow: “Nauka” Publ., 1979:159–167. (In Russ).

Abdurakhman iz Gazikumukha. The book of memories [Kniga vospominaniy]. Makhachkala: Dagestan Books Publishers, 1997:868. (In Russ).

Bobrovnikov V. Abrek. In: G. Krämer, D. Matringe, J. Nawas, E. Rowson, editors. The Encyclopaedy of Islam. 2nd ed. Leiden: E.J. Brill, 2008 (Supplement Vol. Pt. 1):29–30.

Downloads

Published

2020-07-12

Issue

Section

History

How to Cite

1.
Bobrovnikov VO. LEGAL VOCABULARY OF ARABIC-SPEAKING ‘ADAT MONUMENTS IN 14TH-20TH CENTURY DAGESTAN (SOME RESULTS OF THE STUDY OF ISLAMIC DISCOURSES). ИАЭК. 2020;16(2):291-315. doi:10.32653/CH162291-315