THE REGULATION OF ISSUES OF PERFORMING BAPTISM AND OCCASIONAL CHURCH RITUALS IN THE CONTEXT OF RUSSIA-ARMENIA INTERFAITH RELATIONS (1828–1905)

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.32653/CH163565-580

Keywords:

Armenian Apostol Church, Russian Orthodox Church, Russia-Armenia interfaith relations, The Most Holy Governing Synod, church rituals, Echmiadzin Synod.

Abstract

The paper attempts to analyze the regulation of cases, in which Orthodox people would ask to perform baptism and other religious rituals priests of the Armenian Apostol Church, while followers of the Armenian faith – priest of the Orthodox Church, without changing one’s religious affiliation. It has been determined that such situations occurred due to compelling reasons, which entailed negative consequences of the state-legal, church-canonical, everyday nature and led to the separation of families on a confessional basis. For instance, the fact that a child born to an Orthodox spouse was baptized by an Armenian priest was regarded as “leading astray from Orthodoxy”, even if a newborn was seriously ill. If an Armenian child was baptized according to the Orthodox order, then formally he became a member of the Orthodox Church, while his parents continued to belong to the Armenian Apostol Church.

The study uses legislative sources and materials of record-keeping of the National Archive of Armenia and the Russian State Historical Archive. Methodologically, the article is based on systematization, classification and analysis of these documents. The comparative-historical method has been applied to compare facts and events, identify the process of regulating church practical situations and determine their role in the history of Russian-Armenian confessional relations. It has been concluded that, firstly, the incorporation of Eastern Armenia and the Armenian Apostolic Church into Russia led to the emergence of issues of a church-practical nature, which should have been regulated on the basis of the Russian legislation by the governing bodies of the both churches. Secondly, the decree of the Echmiadzin Synod of 1854, which was in force until 1899, granted Armenian priests the right to perform all church sacraments in relation to Armenian children baptized in infancy according to the Orthodox order, provided that the parents, being of Armenian religion, did not give a written commitment to educate them in the Orthodox faith. Thirdly, the patronizing policy of the empire in relation to Orthodoxy and the dominant position of the Russian Church led to complications in the relationship between the Orthodox clergy and the clergy of the Armenian Church. In cases where representatives of the both churches had the initial equal rights to perform public church rituals (for example, the rite of consecration of water on the feast of the Epiphany of our Lord within one city), priority – an¬d, in some cases (as, for example, in 1858 in Astrakhan) – the exclusive right, – was granted to the Russian Orthodox Church.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

  • Vladimir Sergeevic Blohin, Yekaterinburg Orthodox Theological Seminary; Ural State University of Railway Transport.
    Associate professor

References

Armenian churches of the Russian Empire, 1717–1917 [Armyanskie tserkvi Rossiyskoy imperii (1717–1917)]. Yerevan: Tigran Metz, 2009. (In Russ.).

A letter to the Emperor Peter I from the Patriarch of Jeremiah of Constantinople “On the non-baptism of the Lutherans and Calvinists embarking on the pious Greek faith and on their anointing with the holy world”, August 31, 1718 [Gramota gosudaryu Petru I ot Konstantinopol`skogo patriarkha Ieremii «O nekreshhenii vnov` pristupayushikh k blagochestivoy grecheskoy vere lyuteran i kal`vinov i o pomazanii ikh svyaty`m mirom», 31 avgusta 1718 g.]. Complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire since 1649. Vol. V: 1713–1719. St. Petersburg: 2nd Section of His Imperial Majesty Own Chancellery, 1830:586. (In Russ.).

On the observance by the Greek-Russian priests of church rules during baptism and marriage of Armenians, July 3, 1719 [O soblyudenii greko-rossiyskimi svyashhennikami cerkovny`kh pravil pri kreshhenii i braka armyan, 3 iyulya 1719 g.]. Complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire since 1649. Vol. V: 1713–1719. St. Petersburg: 2nd Section of His Imperial Majesty Own Chancellery, 1830:721. (In Russ.).

Nadezhdin NI. The Armenian-Gregorian Church [Armyano-Grigorianskaya tserkov`]. St. Petersburg, 1843. (In Russ.).

A brief study on the history of the Armenian Eastern Church [Kratkiy ocherk istorii Armyanskoy Vostochnoy tserkvi]. Moscow: Pravoslav, 1872. (In Russ.).

Mkhitarianz A. History of the Armenian Church [Istoriya Armyanskoy tserkvi]. Vagharshapat: St. Echmiadzin Press, 1874. (In Russ.).

Galoyan GA. Russia and the peoples of Transcaucasia [Rossiya i narody Zakavkazya]. Moscow: Mysl, 1976. (In Russ.).

Ananyan JA. An Armenian colony of Grigoriopol [Armyanskaya koloniya Grigoriopol`]. Yerevan: AN ArmSSR, 1969. (In Russ.).

Poghosyan LA. An Armenian colony of Armavir [Armyanskaya koloniya Armavira]. Yerevan: AN ArmSSR, 1981. (In Russ.).

Akopyan VZ. The history of the congregation of the Armenian Apostolic Church in Pyatigorsk [Istoriya prikhoda Armyanskoi Apostolskoi Tserkvi goroda Pyatigorska]. Pyatigorsk, 2005:178. (In Russ.).

Vartanyan VG. The Armenian-Gregorian Church in the politics of Emperor Nicholas I [Armyano-Grigorianskaya tserkov` v politike imperatora Nikolaya I]. Rostov-on-Don: Irbis Firm, 1999. (In Russ.).

Vartanyan VG., Kazarov SS. Armenian Apostolic Church on the Don [Armyanskaya Apostol’skaya Tserkov’ na Donu]. Taganrog, 2008. (In Russ.)

Dyakin VS. The national question in the internal politics of tsarism (XIX – beginning of XX centuries) [Nacional`niy vopros vo vnutrenney politike tsarizma (XIX – nachalo XX vv.)]. Saint Petersburg: Liss, 1998:779. (In Russ.).

Kugrysheva EV. History of Armenians in Astrakhan [Istoriya armyan v Astrakhani]. Astrakhan, GP AO “Volga” Publ., 2007. (In Russ.).

Lukyanov SA., Udodov AG. State-legal regulation of the activity of the Armenian-Gregorian Church in the Russian Empire. International Scientific Journal [Gosudarstvenno-pravovoye regulirovaniye deyatel’nosti Armyano-Grigorianskoy Tserkvi v Rossiyskoy imperii // Mezhdunarodnyi nauchno-issledovatel’skii zhurnal], Yekaterinburg, 2016;12(54:4):166-170. (In Russ.).

Ovanesov BT. The Armenian community of the city of Stavropol [Armyanskaya obshchina goroda Stavropolya]. Stavropol, GUP SK “Stavropolskaya local press”, 2005. (In Russ.).

Stepanyants SM. On the history of the Russian Orthodox Church in Armenia [K istorii deyatel’nosti Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi v Armenii]. Scientific reports of Belgorod State University. Series: History. Political science [Nauchnye vedomosti Belgorodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya. Politologiya]. 2008;2(42:6):42-47. (In Russ.).

Tunyan VG. Armenian-Russian Relations in the Church Sphere 1836–1917 [Armyano-russkie otnosheniya v tserkovnoi sfere 1836–1917 gg.]. Ակունք (Akunk) [Akunk], 2013; 2(8):3-23. (In Russ.).

Tunyan VG. The Armenian Church and the autocracy of Russia in the 18th – early 19 centuries: concepts and realities // Տարեգիրք: Գիտական հոդվածների ժողովածու. ԺԱ. – Երեվան: ԵՊՀ հրատարակչություն [Armyanskaya Tserkov’ i samoderzhavie Rossii v XVIII – nachale XIX v.: kontseptsii i realii]. Yearbook. Collection of Scientific Articles, Yerevan, 2016: XI: 344-359. (In Russ.).

Vert P. Head of the Church, subject to the emperor: Armenian Catholicos at the crossroads of the empire’s domestic and foreign policy, 1828–1914 [Glava Tserkvi, poddannyy imperatora: Armyanskiy katolikos na perekrestkakh vnutrenney i vneshney politiki imperii]. Ab Imperio. 2006;3:99-138. (In Russ.).

Guita J. 1700 years of loyalty. History of Armenia and its Church. [1700 let vernosti. Istoriya Armenii i ee Tserkvi]. Moscow: UNISTROY SK, 2005: 141-150. (In Russ.).

Vedyaev AV. Mixed marriages in the Russian Orthodox Church in the Synodal period [Smeshanny`e braki v Russkoy Pravoslavnoy Tserkvi v Sinodal`ny`y period]. Christian reading [Khristianskoe chtenie], 2017;6:203-219. (In Russ.).

Dolzhenko IV. Orthodox congregations of the Yerevan province. Missionary activity (XIX – beginning of XX century) [Pravoslavnye prikhody Yerivanskoy gubernii. Missionerskaya deyatel`nost` (XIX – nachalo XX v.)]. Traditions and modernity [Traditsii i sovremennost`], 2003;2:72-82. (In Russ.).

Ayrapetyan A. The demographic policy of Russia in Eastern Armenia in the 19th century and early 20th century (on the example of the Alexandropol district) // Բանբեր Հայագիտության [Demograficheskaya politika Rossii v Vostochnoy Armenii v XIX v. i nachale XX v. (na primere Aleksandropol`skogo uezda) // Vestnik Armenovedeniya], 2006;2:83-94. (In Russ.).

Downloads

Published

2020-11-01

Issue

Section

History

How to Cite

1.
Blohin VS. THE REGULATION OF ISSUES OF PERFORMING BAPTISM AND OCCASIONAL CHURCH RITUALS IN THE CONTEXT OF RUSSIA-ARMENIA INTERFAITH RELATIONS (1828–1905). ИАЭК. 2020;16(3):565-580. doi:10.32653/CH163565-580